Jump to content

Carmillum

Registered User
  • Posts

    173
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Posts posted by Carmillum

  1. 261999
    261977 So basically, the guy just reported himself for using drain punch?

     

    Joke aside, can anyone confirm that ragequitters are punished when reported or is it a waste of time? Someone told me that staff don't consider it to be a bannable fault. Sadly, the topic was removed since the OP tried to create a "wall of shame" by publicly exposing some players name.

     

    i think its bannable, if you can provide proof of him being a repeat offender.

     

    No, it is not. Or give a proof it is (admin quote and written in an official post like the one with the Moves).

    And it's not because it is impossible to prove that the dc was on purpose.

  2. No need to attack me personally, I did not do that when I replied to you.

     

    The argument of a reward is needed is invalid, yet I agreed on it since it makes the stuff more attractive - but it's absolutely not a must, like you seemed to pretend in one of your previous message.

     

    Won't argue longer on the rest, like others has told, we do not know what will happen. However, a percentage would be great.

  3. 259603
    259574

    However, I agree with what you said after that, this coin system is extremly unfair. Actually, only good players will get, in the end, the reward. Even if Futz is claiming that this system is made to encourage people to play PVP, this argument just makes me laugh. Do you remember guys when you started PVP ? I started in PRO (never played elsewhere) and I barely won 10 matches in a season and had several time the pleasure to lose 5 times or more in a row. Some people will try hard, others will give up quickly.

     

    I remember the 1st time i start PvP on last march, my score was like 30 - 70 (win - lose). I lose a lot & i might win just by luck at that time, since i have no slight idea about pokemon battle (this is my 1st pokemon game). With the coins system at least that kind of struggle wont going to waste since you still get an amount of coins and give you purpose on pvp even though you got [Censored] team. Giving up is their mental issue, you can't really do anything about that and it have no relevance with coin system because with or without it people with that kind of mentality will giving up eventually. So yea the coin reward at least encourage most people to keep doing PvP.

     

    259574

    This system is very clearly only one-way. And the biggest injustice is that top-ladder will receive an ENORMOUS amount of coins IN ADDITION to all the ones they won by climbing it up.

     

    To summarize, the coin system sucks.

     

    If everyone win the same rewards in the end, the Competition LOSE ITS VERY PRINCIPLE :D:

     

    Of course, we all agree on this. Their must be a reward for the "best", to make PVP even more attractive, even if - let's be honest -, without reward people would still play it, at least for the sake of being top ladder. Your argument is fully invalid. And what makes me tick, is that the "best" receive 700 coins. 700. It's insane. Did you see the price of the PVP-coin stuff ?! 300k for a toxic orb (50 coins) -> this makes out of a PVP winner a 4 million $ reward *. If you were in front of me, I would ask you : Look me in the eyes and tell me this is fair.

     

    700 coins is obvious overly abusive. Admit it. I am not able to reach top ladder (I am trying hard), but with such a bait, maybe i'll consider playing like an A** only to grab those 4 millions.

     

    Do you see the problem ? Rewarding is great. Rewarding too much breaks the funny point of a game, since people will not come here for the beauty of the game, but only to get this reward. The previous system was much better (a cloak, showing that you earn your prestige! We should get rid of the new one. ASAP!

     

    * even if price will very likely decrease by half in the next weeks, you can consider the reward being a minimum 1,5 million gain.

  4. 259420 There is a surrender option in almost every single pvp based game in the world. Adding a Surrender option would be a good alternative, however as others have stated, there is the win trading issue. Rewarding the opponent with a win upon a surrender doesn't seem right.

     

    :Cry:

     

    What the hell are you saying ?! If I feel I lost and I don't want to waste my time, I surrender. Surrending = losing. Losing = the opponent wins, and thus he can be rewarded for that. :Angry:

     

    However, I agree with what you said after that, this coin system is extremly unfair. Actually, only good players will get, in the end, the reward. Even if Futz is claiming that this system is made to encourage people to play PVP, this argument just makes me laugh. Do you remember guys when you started PVP ? I started in PRO (never played elsewhere) and I barely won 10 matches in a season and had several time the pleasure to lose 5 times or more in a row. Some people will try hard, others will give up quickly.

     

    This system is very clearly only one-way. And the biggest injustice is that top-ladder will receive an ENORMOUS amount of coins IN ADDITION to all the ones they won by climbing it up.

     

    To summarize, the coin system sucks.

  5. I think we agree in the end. Admins just should add a surrender button (which I would use if I feel I cannot deal with the stalling - I don't always have the proper team to counter it.). Yet, disconnecting on an endless battle, I would be curious to know how (and especially why) the admins could inflict some kind of punishment lol. This remains a game, we all need to have fun with it. Surely it's not fun not to receive your coin, but come on, it's not like you are not receiving your ladderpoints.

     

    I would like to add that I am not defending people who are constantly dc. That's really not nice. I was only giving my point of view on a specific situation.

    Dc.

    Life is hard :Ambivalent:

    51 wins, 40 coins

     

    Keep winning, you'll make it.

    However, if you are a staller, do not wonder that people may log out more often vs you.

  6. 258098
    258090 Someone added me as a friend to tell me he is gonna report me because I crashed when I was about to lose and this is a bannable offense. However, I can't see it stated anywhere that this is bannable? Is it or not?

     

    Kagawa(staff) said:

    If you have sufficient evidence that the player is abusing it on purpose, it is reportable.

    Otherwise, no.

     

    Since u arent d/c-ing on purpose i wouldnt be to worried about it even if it gets reported. I would report u too since i dont know if it was on purpose or not. So if it happens a lot that a person is disconnecting on purpose, staff will notice that and punish this behaviour.

     

    Haha, how could this be reportable? If I want to leave the game, I can. I won't force my self to finish an endless battle (my main cause of logging out during a battle - because YES i am doing it.). (And I enjoy it, when the first 10 minutes where only about switching in/out slowbro, sableye, skarmo, donphan and so on.). No point wasting my time and, if I may say so, not worth giving a coin. How can you blame a player for it? This is totally stupid -> blame the admins, if they can't code this properly and did not think of testing all the issues before releasing this feature.

  7. PVP knowledge first. If some people are playing commonly Natural Cure Pokemons on another way, too bad. If your Blissey/Roserade/Starmie is asleep, your opponent can freely use Spore/Sleep Powder/Yawn on any other of your pokemons.

     

    HOWEVER -> You can try to fix this by contacting your opponent, telling him that your pokemon does not have Natural Cure, and that now that he knows it, he will have to respect the sleep clause. On the other hand, if you are "the opponent", feel free to take a screenshot of the conversation, and report the guy if he lies to you (+eventually expose his name here, so that we know who we can't trust).

  8. 257133 :confused:

     

    https://pokemonrevolution.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=98&t=44244

     

    https://pokemonrevolution.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=33054&start=80

    9 and onwards, prob some sites later too.

     

    https://pokemonrevolution.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=34240&start=160

    This site and onward, prob some sites later too. ;)

     

    https://pokemonrevolution.net/forum/viewtopic.php?f=98&t=35761

    Another whole discussion

     

    Here u find some answers.^^

    Ima not discussing this again, hf. :Heart:

     

    Bla bla bla, stop arguing about this topic, everything has been said, please follow the links in Coop's post. Having 30 times the same discussion won't bring anything more than content pollution.

  9. 253282

     

    nb: I'd need to know what could 1hko a +6 Gothitelle. Everyone is running it Bold + max def and once it uses calm mind 6 times it got an insane amount of sdef. The difference is, once he is at +6, he will 1hko everything of your team for sure unless you got something it cannot hits. A pokemon that let you a chance "only if" isnt that good for the metagame.

     

    Weavile.

    You're welcome!

    Or Tyranitar with Lum-Berry & Crunch if the Goti has Thunderwave & a PSY move (enables a DD that may help to sweep).

  10. I don't get it.

     

    Gothithelle can not help you to "win the game". Actually Gothi will mostly only kill 1 pokemon. Maybe two if you are late game and you have nothing to OHKO it. End.

    BellyDrum Azu is the very same. Will generally kill 1 pokemon or 2 (or full sweep) before you manage to take it out if you don't have the proper counter). Same goes for weather sweeper, and lots of other pokemons. Why should Gotithelle be banned for? This pokemon remains a cure to the abusive use of stalling here. Don't knock it away. :confused:

     

    It's not like Wobbuffet, where an endless battle is very much possible (and I believe this is mostly why shadow tag was banned in competitions, since Gothithelle arrived after Wobbuffet) - Wobb should be banned in PRO.

×
×
  • Create New...