Marksmancl

yes, it is the same

Is there any chance you can tell me the ID of the pokemon he showed to Oak?

Hi, his username is xWarGreyx, he has a character in the gold server. Thank you for your assistance

Hi. No, he didnt show any other pokemon besides charmander (after he captured it) and charizard (once he trained it and evolved it). He has blastoise and a venusaur, but both are not level 100 and were captured before the quest started. It seems he tried to fight Oak but his team had more than 1 pokemon, so oak rejected the battle, then when he came back, Oak didn´t want to battle him.

Hi, he showed it to Oak when it was still a charmander, in fact Oak agreed that it could handle the mega evolution, instead of saying " thats not the pokemon i asked for". In fact he has no other charmander/squirtle/bulbasaur that meet the requirements of the quest.

nope, its already back to full happiness

Hi everyone, my friend is having an issue with the charizardite y quest. He followed all the steps of the quest according to the guide: caught a new charmander with 91+ ivs and a desired nature, showed it to Oak, leveled him up, trained evs, full happiness but Oak doesn´t accept him (even though Oak said it was a fine charmander the first time he showed it to him), he says that it was not what he asked for. There is something else i must add, my friend doesn´t have fly HM, so he traded it to me, and i taught him fly... As we thought that might have triggered this issue, he replaced fly with seismic toss, but the issue remains. We think the fact that he traded it to me might have "blocked" the pokemon for Oak. Is there any chance anyone can help us? We would be very grateful if someone does. PS: my friend doesn´t know much English, so i'm helping him.

I have the same issue... i also tried to evolve eevee into sylveon in love island but it didn't evolve