Just something I want to clear up about this bit @GoldenP1kachu
I'm not saying no one doesn't care about guild island, I actually do like guild island. I'm referring to previous messages from Walross himself about his feelings on guild island, which is why I was expecting a reply of the same nature.
I agree here that people shouldn't be able to fight for two guilds but its not gonna make it more competitive, its just gonna make gold guilds take even more of a hit as silver doesnt have this problem in my opinion, the guild ladder is gonna be lower, the queue will have less people in it and I think the problem is beyond that.
I also think you are downplaying the state of the guild scene when you said this to be honest, silver has never been this dead, there has always been 3 guilds competing for the top spot with 4th knocking on the door. Gold on the other hand has been one guild dominating for as long as I can remember which is why I didn't really mention gold in my post because it has been that way for too long and simply doesnt have enough players to pvp to make it competitive, silver will slowly reach that level of even more boring competition as more veterans of the game are quitting as the weeks go by because they are fed up and in general just cannot be arsed.