I've been enjoying Guild Island so far, however.. Various problems were encountered:
-The location for the Spawn Ranger should be either in the Pokecenter or closer to it, because right now where it is, a lot of people miss it, thus making it so nobody votes.
-The voting system and spawn rotation needs improvement. I agree with someone else in this post, the spawns should be longer than 2 days but no longer than 3, so people that invested in a BMS for a certain spawn, can get the most out of it. Silver experienced "Trick Room" spawn for several days because people were not voting. Because of this, we havent fully experienced everything Guild Island has to offer, because we haven't gotten some of the other spawns available for it.
Suggestion: Maybe the Spawn Ranger could do a better job at the conservation of the spawns by making it unavailable to vote for the same spawn twice in a row, or if the requirements are not met (people not voting for a change) then he can rotate the spawn to the next spawn available in the voting list.