9 hours ago, Clumsyclef said:

PvP-usaged-based spawns could be an option in the future as well, it really depends of the time of year as a lot of players seemed to like the event-based spawns. Unfortunately its not possible to please everyone equally but I will suggest it for a time it may fit.

A voting and rotational system as it was is unlikely to return but there are different ideas to improve Guild Island already.

 

I am not sure if I understand you correctly as this has been already the case for the previous months now.

My point is this :

Let us have 4 spawn rotation in every 3 months with small outbreak mons just to be guild island alive . They can be picked as vote from all top 3-10 guilds and be rotated in every 3 months . That way the competition for top 3 will be more meanful. 

Also put this in PRO announcement so all can try to reach top 3 , or if they want to use the option with 20 mysterious tickets .

And last : just personal opinion. 

Its looks bad this thing to not be fixed or at least when there is spawn update to dont be announced. I will state some facts to see and feel my frustration. 
I did our first entry with 20 mysterious tickets when spawn worked with the vote system, for much than half of our guild memebers was good and hunt was good. Next month we made top 3 and we get stuck on this stall for idk what time. I know that perioud was bad for all, but for some guilds guild island is something we hope to be worty for us. Then suddenly after like 6 months -1 year of nothing spawn was changed when our guild was out of top 3. We could at least get announcement for it because some guilds ( i wont mentioned names ) had decent spot for hunt of pokemons ( even event forms before the event map was out ) , and we wasnt happy about it because if we knew that gonna happen we could enter with tickets aswell and was a bit unfair for all. 

SO pls make guild island alive . 4 diffrent spawns or at least outbreak Pokemon in every 3 months and put it as announcement in fist 2 days at the start of the month so all guilds would know and pick his choice ( do they want to pay the fee, be in battle for top 3 or not )

 

22 hours ago, Clumsyclef said:

That being said, we are aware that Guild Island needs to be improved as a whole and its planned for the future to have it reworked.

As I mentioned we are aware that Guild Island is not in a good state and needs big changes which are planned for the future.

Unfortunately not everything can be done at the same time and instantly, these things take a lot of time as we do not want to do this things half-hearted.

i can udnerstand that , i just hope after those changes if there is any update on it at least all should be prepared for it