If the same topic comes up and up and up again... then maybe blocking it from the list is not the way to go. A serious discussion in order to find a solution would rather be advisable. If it is annoying for certain people that are somehow involved into the realization of mentioned feature or decission takers (of which mods are neither nor, correct me if I am wrong), wherefore they cannot participate in a constructive discussion, then maybe those people should not get involved into further discussions about this topic. As I said before, a simple "no" wont make it. List the issues and let the community suggest you detailed measurements against those issues. If nothing new comes up and the issues cannot be solved, the topic should be trashed by making an official statement on the forums and the log in screen of the game. However, since this suggestion seems to be new and was not considered before (it is not perfect and has to be further elaborated for sure), I guess we did not reach this state yet.

 

PS: I am not a big fan of breeding either, but I understand both parties.

even when u cant trade bred pokes it will hurt the economy a lot since it decreases the demandside... a poorly thought out mechanic imo sry

Before u give me the "BREDDING WILL NEVER BE ADDED" Atleast read what im saying. One of the main reasons breeding isnt in is because of the broken economic system it can create BUT..this can be avoided easy.

 

BREADING WILL NEVER BE ADDED!

 

About economy system; who will ever buy pokemons if everyone could bread for a perfect one?

 

:)

Bounding breeding to an account will still cripple the economy as everyone will only need to find a say Scyther to be able to breed his/her way to a perfect one. Limiting the breed to one breed per poke won't have as big an impact but it will still alter prices heavily given that now every good natured pokemon is a potential tool to breed a good pokemon.

 

Either way the only way to actually preserve the economy as it is is without adding breeding.

Breeding is bad for a Pokemon MMO. Nothing more to say.

If the same topic comes up and up and up again... then maybe blocking it from the list is not the way to go. A serious discussion in order to find a solution would rather be advisable. If it is annoying for certain people that are somehow involved into the realization of mentioned feature or decission takers (of which mods are neither nor, correct me if I am wrong), wherefore they cannot participate in a constructive discussion, then maybe those people should not get involved into further discussions about this topic. As I said before, a simple "no" wont make it. List the issues and let the community suggest you detailed measurements against those issues. If nothing new comes up and the issues cannot be solved, the topic should be trashed by making an official statement on the forums and the log in screen of the game. However, since this suggestion seems to be new and was not considered before (it is not perfect and has to be further elaborated for sure), I guess we did not reach this state yet.

 

PS: I am not a big fan of breeding either, but I understand both parties.

 

You're right. I don't make decisions about features, but I do respond to suggestions on the forums. If you read my other post, I also direct users to other threads so that they are able to read discussions about suggestions that have already been made. In those posts, you will see detailed explanations as to why breeding will not be included in PRO by people that do make those decisions. :)

 

You may also notice that this thread isn't locked. The community is allowed to make suggestions and discuss them as much as they would like as long as it remains civil. Just don't expect the staff to immerse themselves in a conversation they've had 1000 times before.

IMO Breeding is bad and should never ever be implemented, at least in a Pokemon MMO game.