After playing this game for over a month here's a few pros and cons I've seen to it. Things I'd change and things I wouldn't. Feel free to submit your own.
Pros:
- The game is relatively glitch free, which is rare for a fan-made video game,
- No breeding system is great. Good pokemon are actually rare, and let's be honest, pokemon like milktank laying eggs is a silly and quite frankly anti-educational idea for kids.
- Staff responds quickly to almost everything. To be fair this can be a double edged blade (see cons) but it's nice when justice is server rightfully.
- The game designers have taken some freedom with writing the story, which is better than just copy/pasting one of the pokemon games,
- Some boss fights are challenging, especially early on,
- Game actually starts from Gen I, and moves on from that, and we can chose pikachu,
- The main menu is very nice looking.
Cons:
- Excessive anti-profanity rules, and excessive rule enforcment in general. Having a censor is fine (having a censor you can disable even better) but you can still get kicked after the censor has done its job? Really?
- Due to this and due to most moderator's blind faith in the rules, some of them often fill in the Lawful Evil cliché at times (the Dolores Umbridge types).
- An unreasonably large portion of the community is pretty stuckup or uptight. Backseat moderating, condescending attitudes, uncapable of taking any jokes. Possibly a by-product of the excessively strict rules.
- Some of the soundtracks in game are awful and make it feel like we're in circus or something,
- No option to join Team Rocket... we've been waiting for this forever! A fan made video game is the opportunity to make these things happen.
- Some pokemon like Zapdos are unobtainable. This is a crime, everyone loves Zapdos!