Karyoplasma

Sorry for the late reply. I don't check the forums much these days since I'm not actively playing anymore. The spawn chance predictions were a side project of mine to evaluate farming spots and were founded on the idea that each tier had a weight attached to it. The weights were estimated using collected spawn data from BetterFarm. I hunted X-mas Axew in 2020 and it took 47.6k encounters and I had the tier data via the spawn dump (I also had some help from clan members that farmed a lot and provided their data for me). I simply added all weights from a route and divided the tier weight by the total weight for the spawn chance and then manually adjusted the estimated weights until they roughly aligned with my data sets. What I didn't know was that there always have been more than 9 tiers even tho reborn only showed 9. In reality, there are sub-tiers that vary greatly in chance, about like the way it is presented now with common, uncommon, rare, just that there are common T9, uncommon T9 and rare T9 tiers (many different ones for each group). I assumed they were all weighted equally, so the spawn chance prediction was never accurate and there won't ever be a way to accurately predict them unless the spawn editors decide to make the weights public. The only thing you can do to get an accurate spawn prediction is to go to a spawn and then count what you encounter for a long, long time and then you will have a reliable representation of what to expect on that spot. The rarer a spawn, the more encounter data you would need to collect and you also have to collect it in an unbiased manner, so you'll need at least more than 20k encounters in your data set and you have to make sure that you don't run into sampling biases (stop collecting data on a particularly bad or good streak). The tier1-9 data was just part of the spawn data back then. They have removed it since because it was, as elaborated above, misleading. I assume they didn't want to keep conveying the idea that there are only 9 spawn tiers.

Added the release to the initial post, so you don't have to go on github xD

Hey, I pretty much completely rewrote everything. The old version is pretty useless by now because so many spawns changed and it doesn't work with the new spawn dump structure, so there is no feasible way to update the spawn database. The spawn chance predictions are gone because the new spawn dumps don't provide the information required for it to work. It was more guesswork than provably correct in the first place. With no further ado, I present to you the 2023 Update: Feature changes: Better Spellchecker - The old one had some annoying bugs, this one should work more reliably and less intrusively. Better presentation of results - No more issues with spacing! Better GUI - You can resize the application window now without breaking everything. Also, right-clicking in the result table opens a pop-up menu that lets you copy or directly search for what's below. Better internals - Finally using Java8 standard methods instead of relying on very old ones. Better repel check - The old one was very unreliable, so wrote a new one from scratch. It should be more accurate and less prone to breaking. It should also work for time-sensitive repel spawns if there are any. Better updating - You can keep the spawn dumps and the files that depend on it updated by letting the app handle all the downloading and replacing. Don't worry about flooding PRO's servers, the routine makes sure that an update is reasonable before connecting to the server. Better maintainability - If you are modifying and building this app yourself, you will find that the new structure is way more intuitive. The GUI now actually only does GUI stuff instead of being a band-aid for everything. ActionEvents are handled by different classes, so there is no overlap in functionality. Enjoy. I figured it would be better to publish this is a new thread because it's basically a completely new application behind the same idea. Due to heavy refactoring and rewriting, this version is not compatible with the old one at all, so please report any issues or requests you have with the 2023 edition in this new thread instead. Link to github repository: https://github.com/Karyoplasma/PROkedex Link to release: https://github.com/Karyoplasma/PROkedex/releases/tag/2023Update PROkedex 2023 Update.zip

I voted "Yes", but I think you should limit the announcement to uncommon or rarer on Shiny pokemon. Rare-only for event forms seems appropriate, else it would be too spammy. Displaying the username should 100% stay opt-in, maybe even make a notification window pop up when you enable it that warns about potential scams from shylocks eagle-eyeing these announcements.

No need to release your Darkrai. Just try to enter the castle and the Dark Realm again. If you can't, you have to defeat Horon in Dark Valley without losing a pokemon in the battle to regain entry. Once inside the Dark Realm, defeat Umbra (the Mega Gengar) in a fight in which you can only use your Clefairy. Make sure to recruit all possible team members (Clefairy, Growlithe, Munna, Cubone and Alolan Rattata) before you leave the Dark Realm.

They contain a Halloween-themed accessory to equip on your character.

The unfair advantage is that you would force everyone to install a third party software to have the same "convenience" of moving left and right automatically. Not sure how that is hard to see, honestly. It's automating the game by removing a core game mechanic, yes moving left and right through grass is a core game mechanic in Pokemon games. Alternate between hands when farming to reduce the pain. Or use a controller.

+1

None of the players in PRO are "war criminals". By dehumanizing and categorizing people into good/civilized and bad/"apes", you are achieving nothing and are falling into the same trap that was used to justify the invasion to the Russian public. "We" have to do nothing and doing nothing will not put "us" in a bad light, don't worry. This will be my last reply, have a good Halloween event.

Nobody is invading you through PRO. Keep your political agenda out of video games, especially if they are fanmade and non-profit.

Pretty sure, nicknaming has been requested and denied in the past because of concerns in moderation. It will certainly be abused, so it will probably never be implemented.

Don't focus on a full team, it'll be harder than rolling everything with 2, maximum 3, pokemon. Chimchar is a beast and can pretty much solo with Nasty Plot, Grass Knot, Flamethrower, Brick Break. Good complimentary pokemon that you can catch early would be Psyduck (Surf, Psychic, Ice Beam, Calm Mind), Shinx (Thunderwave, Baby-Doll Eyes/Flash, Spark/Wild Charge, Crunch), Abra (Psychic, Shadowball, Calm Mind), Geodude (Earthquake, Stealth Rock, Rock Tomb, Toxic) and Gligar (Sword Dance, Earthquake, Acrobatics, Roost). Just pick what you like and then go ham.

Link to Hoenn post Sinnoh playthrough screenshots: Thoughts: I used the EXP Share throughout the whole region sharing experience between Chimchar and Starly for the whole time. As you may see from the screenshots, it worked well, but at times it was a hassle to keep switching the item from one poke to the other. As a sidenote here, starter RNG is dumb, I got -Speed nature in 3 out of 4 regions, almost wanting to abandon my starters every time. There should be an option to "reroll" your starter into a neutral nature, 11-19 in all IVs pokemon before getting the first badge, so you won't be sad if you get a crippling nature on your starter. The region's difficulty was alright if you only use 2 pokemon. I fought every trainer on every route and felt on level for the most part up until the Byron gym, where the difficulty spiked a bit. I would have maybe wished to be a couple levels higher at some points like the Cyrus fight in Distortion World. Also the Giratina fight afterwards did not reward me with any XP, not sure if that is a bug or not. The legendary fights in Hoenn and Sinnoh are ridiculously difficult to the point that you pretty much have to cheese them unless you want to kill wilds for hours to end. You will be outsped and oneshot otherwise and it's a potential road block if you don't have Sturdy statusers. At around high in the level 40s, you can really feel the experience gain to drop off and every level after that is a struggle. I really fear having to level a pokemon, nevermind a full team, to 100 for PvP or bosses. After almost 62 hours and 4 regions, I still did not have a single lvl 100. Granted I still have like 30 rare candies because I deliberately did not use them, but Rare Candies shouldn't be a necessity to reach 100, they should complement it by skipping the most brutal part of the last couple levels. I don't really see a way to get my pokemon to 100 now that I cannot farm the E4s anymore, there are no good leveling options. Maybe Ceru Cave is alright, I don't know because I cannot access it and won't be catching 240 pokemon to unlock it. Summarizing pros and cons that I noted during my playthrough: + EXP Share does what it's supposed to do, no complaints here Not being utterly punished for evolving your pokemon feels way more natural than on live Catch experience makes the beginning of the region smooth Getting EV training with the EXP share is helpful, but should be a toggle feature - Experience gain after high level 40 is way too slow It's not viable to run more than 2 pokemon in your team during a region's story Sturdy toxic/para/rock tomb is required for some parts No good leveling option other than spamming Elite 4

Link to Johto post Hoenn playthrough screenshots: Thoughts: Hoenn story was fine. Being able to evolve makes Winona in Fortree City less of a ridiculous difficulty spike, but it's still by far the hardest gym for where it's at in the story. I also struggled with Mossdeep, but that was my own fault since I pretty much just beelined there after the Aqua&Magma quest and didn't fight the optional trainers on the water routes. I did full-clear all the hideouts and then just wanted to progress, it's a very long stretch of the story, so I got a bit antsy I guess. After finishing the Soothopolis gym, I farmed a Clefairy with the Bold sync Natu I caught early on in Kanto and then trained it for the Sinnoh entry quest. Here, I have a couple of suggestions: make the EV Wald Safari area available to be visited in all regions. You cannot catch anything there anymore and there is no PC, so it being locked to Kanto makes no sense at all. Also add a quest for a non-Wailmer Surf Mount somewhere around Lilycove similar to the Arcanine mount quest in Kanto. You will have to surf a lot after that point and the regular surf speed is just ugh. After training came the most cancerous part: leveling 6 mons to lvl80 to be able to access Sinnoh. This was hell. I farmed the Hoenn E4 over and over and over. I didn't count how many runs it took. The wilds in Hoenn Victory Road are simply not high level enough to matter anymore EXP-wise, the trainers there were a decent source of levels tho. The EXP Share was of course very helpful with this task, but leveling takes too long. It's so grindy and bad that people hunt and level Nincada, so they can delay evolution until 80 and then get 2 mons for the price of one, just to fulfill the requirement. I'll say it again: the EXP gained is too little, it will drive away many players. The fights to enter Sinnoh themselves are fine. I did have a really good Masquerain tho (Calm 25+ in relevant IVs), so I could just quiverpass +6 onto Clefable and sweep Charon. Summarizing, I would say that the story part of Hoenn was the smoothest of the 3 regions I've played so farm in terms of EXP progression, just the part after the story was ridiculously grindy.

Kanto feedback post Johto screenshots: As you may see from my "team", it was another instance of "get sturdys to debuff and then setup and sweep". Experience gain is just too low to try anything else, you will fall behind too much. I have used the EXP Share in the beginning, mainly because I wanted Stealth Rock on Graveler and that put my starter pretty behind, so after the rock hit 30, I stopped using it for the rest of the region. I EV-trained to make up for the lack of levels on my starter; leveling another mon alongside would have been a no go in the long run. I did some wild EXP test in Blackthorn and leveled from 71 to 72 on my Feraligatr in Dragons Den, here are the screens of that expedition: As you can see, it took almost 25 fights to get a single level, so I just didn't bother to level up more and went to the gym. Clair+gym was a sweep, don't think I even used any potions. I didn't take a screenshot before entering E4 because I was debating whether I should farm them for a bit, but ultimately decided against it. I farmed will twice on my Butterfree, but it was honestly more of a struggle than just pressing on, so I stopped quickly.