Shadow pokemon

[Isildurr2x]

-1

[Dos3d]

Just delete them entirely lol.

[Thedark]

-1
People waste days looking for the best tactic to get the highest possible score in dungeons (more competitive than PvP right now tbh). After a long time something has finally been added to reward these people (shadow forms), so I think it's only right that it stays that way. As with PvP, effort should be rewarded.

[Cattybandit]

-1, maybe increase it to top 4 or top 5, but I feel that it should remain a pve reward.

[Dorade]

+1

top 3 seems tough... not sure it will benefits to many people...

For instance one of the top 3 guild on dungeon ladder board today is frozen which have 28 players...

So what does it mean ? I need to join this guild to get shadow poke ? While i would have not even participated in doing the dungeon... how fair is it compared to people that went into dungeon and get no reward cause not top 3...

Edited February 3, 2023 by Dorade

[Tcjp]

+1

 

[Alciuz]

-1

top 3 pvp guilds are there because they have players good in pvp, they get guild island with spawns they can choose and tutors they can choose + players in top 3 guilds most likely provide actively to the ratings of the guild being good in pvp, therefore have more access to exclusive pvp-coins rewards.

top 3 pve guilds grind hours and hours and, considering that is not easy to be there as a party of 4 or 5 to grind, it's only fair that the game rewards that grind in an exclusive way.

[0danobunaga]

Not everyone in the guild able to access shadow pokemon area even guild in pve ladder, similar with pvp not everyone able to access guild island because requirement. It is fair to everyone. Also, that area only 1 hour able to go inside not like guild island access 24/7. 

In addition, dungeon still need Twin Dragon Orb to access Victini dungeon and only obtainable in Medusa/Eldir and Lance boss, it is not easy to get Twin Dragon Orb and still need to wait 2 week for a battle boss. Unlike PvP just stay Pokemon Center and click the Pvp button.

Therefore, I am not agree let everyone to access it.

Edited February 4, 2023 by 0danobunaga

[Lyn1311]

if want to be fair, let all player have access for that but have some kind condition like pay 1 myst ticket for minimum access. if you want to be free, go ask your friend and join the ladder. Or could be nice if it has individual score, and player with certain minimum score can access it with very limited time

 

Not everyone has guild with active player and have bunch of free time. Beside if want it to be special or exclusive, make it not tradeable

 

Besides, ladder not something that reset every week, waiting 1 month to access it kinda too long  

 

Different with guild island, spawn there only have one purpose, for pvp, and not everyone doing pvp stuff so if its limited for pvp player it sounds fair, but for form, iam pretty sure theres a lot player who only collect OT shiny or form in this game

 

with rules only 3 guild can access that area, just like guild island there a chance 95% player will never ever have a chance to access the area even if they really want to

 

lastly even on top 3 pve guild, its not like every member done that dungeon. 

[Osean02]

-1 I like the idea of making it accessible to everyone but it's just unfair to those pve guilds who worked really hard on achieving top 3 on dungeon ladder.

 

I suggest they create other ways to gain access to it other than being in one of the top 3 dungeon guilds. Just like guild island which can also be accessed by contributing 20 mysterious tickets. Since it's only 1 hour a day, i think it's also fair to lower the requirements (if by mysterious tickets, then i say 10-15 tickets per guild)