This is just a personal take regarding the presentation of auctions and in particular the growing use of AI or other tools to illustrate what is being sold. I've noticed that some players are starting to use AI-generated images or similar methods to showcase Pokémon in their auctions. While I can understand the appeal, these images can look impressive, dramatic and naturally draw more attention to a sale, I think there is a problem with using them.

I love using AI myself, and I think it has plenty of benefits, whether that's just for fun or for professional purposes. But I also think there's a time and place for it, and when it comes to something like a forum auction, I feel it starts getting into risky territory.

The main issue for me is accuracy and consistency. AI-generated images don't always represent the Pokémon being sold exactly as it appears in-game. An image might get a number wrong, display an ability or detail incorrectly, or make some other small change that isn't immediately obvious. Even if the mistake is minor and completely unintentional, it can still create confusion because the image is presenting something that may not be an exact representation of what the player is actually selling.

That's where I think AI could unintentionally become a trouble-causer. It doesn't necessarily require anyone to have bad intentions. A seller might simply want to make their auction look more attractive, but an AI-generated image could introduce an incorrect detail that the seller themselves doesn't notice. Then you potentially have disagreements over what was advertised, what a buyer thought they were bidding on, or whether something was misleading. It also leaves moderators having to judge situations that could have been avoided in the first place.

Of course, we already have rules against scamming, deliberately misleading or deceiving players, and manipulating information. My suggestion isn't aimed at intentional deception though. It's more about preventing these grey areas and having a consistent standard for everyone before the use of AI and similar tools becomes more common.

I think a simple solution would be to require that when visually showcasing the Pokémon being auctioned, players use a direct in-game screenshot from PRO of the Pokémon on offer. AI-generated images or images produced through third-party tools shouldn't be used as a substitute for that.

This wouldn't stop people from making their auctions look appealing through formatting or general presentation. It's about making sure that when you're showing the Pokémon being sold, what the buyer sees comes directly from the game and is an accurate representation of what they're bidding on.

AI is a great tool and I'm certainly not against its use, but I think auctions are one of those situations where keeping things simple, direct and verifiable is probably better for everyone. Having a clear standard now could save both players and moderators a lot of confusion and disputes later on, especially as AI and similar tools become more used.

Edited 1 hour ago1 hr by Lacomus

+1

AI can make mistakes.

The hosts can have whatever they want, but it would be great if they could also add the actual screenshot/image as a reference.

For example, if the AI gets a Pokémon’s gender wrong, that could be a pretty significant mistake. Having the original screenshot/image would make it easier to verify the information.

+1

+1

+1

+1