Spawn feedback thread (August 2023+)

[Corv1knight]

Bittersweet cave 4f

Personally, Panchams feel slightly rarer than they should be. Please consider making one common tier in the map, swinub, lower level than 20 so that there can be an option for it to be repelled away, similar to gastlies in necropolis/dark valley.

Edited October 30, 2023 by Corv1knight

[Quaquaval]

On 10/29/2023 at 11:24 AM, Pukje said:

Map: route 214

 

The spawns feel a bit crowded with all that is there especially with the rare slots.

4 rare slots feels a bit to much espeically  during certain times of day. During mornings it really feels bad cause its 4 of them that fight over the spawn %.

Hi @Pukje,
we checked route 214 spawn and overall is fine.
Having more pokemon rare in one single spawn doesn't mean they have less chance to appear.
 

 

On 10/30/2023 at 1:05 PM, Corv1knight said:

Bittersweet cave 4f

Personally, Panchams feel slightly rarer than they should be. Please consider making one common tier in the map, swinub, lower level than 20 so that there can be an option for it to be repelled away, similar to gastlies in necropolis/dark valley.

Hi @Corv1knight,
Pancham encounter chance in Bittersweet Cave 4f is totally fine for a Rare pokemon.
Gastly level is not low to incentivate the strategy to avoid commons pokemon, as you can see from the pokedex after a certain level Gastly's family learn a self harming move and we want to avoid this in the future spawns.

Thanks for the feedback.
Have a great day and enjoy your hunt!

[Finnderboss]

carnivine used to be one of the rarest pokes in game now he has so many spawns and even uncommon?! it was just headbutt uncommon before and safari / ms exlcusive rare in wild. next event make beldum and zorua uncommon in 3 spots pls xD and solosis seems like its everywhere too now it used to be crazy hard to hunt.
bouffalant too in the snow event, its an african animal at least make it logical if u want to take away the exclusiveness of certain pokes..

Edited December 3, 2023 by Finnderboss

[Phuongismylife]

2023 xmas eevee new form rate in all map except event map:
I myself encountered 2 xmas but always old form, and I observe about 3-5 other players found the same old form instead of new form eevee, is the rate not 50/50 or are there any error here?

[Closecombat]

Hello @Finnderboss, @Phuongismylife

 

 

Carnivine and Pokemon Rarity adjustement:

 

The game is evolving and some things need to be corrected and changed.

The choice of Carnivine as a rare pokemon is rather "debatable",the pokemon was initially placed as a rare pokemon without any real reason behind it and the  only reason why  Carnivine was at one point one of the "rarest pokemon in the game" is the lack of spawn and accessibility to its spawns without any real reason.

 

So the fact that carnivine was one of the "rarest pokemon in the game" is only because of his accessibility and its lacking spawns without any real reason + the fact that the vast majority of pokemon players don't care about carnivine in general and won't farm it because the pokemon isn't popular at all and has practically no use / interest for it.

 

Hence the explanation as why the pokemon is one of the "rarest ingame pokemons" and the explanation of why the pokemon had nothing to do as rare pokemon and needed to be readjusted.

its not the case only of carnivine others are in the same case, some 5/6g pokemon also requires a tier readjustment and its a change necessary to ensure a certain logic in the spawns of the pokemon and their rarity.

All pokemon cannot and should not be rare especially without any reason behind that and this is why some change need to be made.

 

 I agree that the ideal would have been that the pokemon was not a rare pokemon since the beginning to avoid this loss of rarity that the pokemon undergoes but unfortunately there is no good time to make this kind of change that are necessarty and must be done. (we already got in the past Starly and wingull as exemple as Rare pokemon wich are now common) 

 

comparing carnivine with zorua and beldum makes no sense at all. beldum and zorua are pokemon that are very usefull or appreciated and very popular by the pokemon fan base or was also rare in the Original Game, thats  absolutely the opposite for carnivine, which is largely ignored by the general public. 

 

"take away the exclusiveness of certain pokes".

 

There is a huge difference between a pokemon volontary exclusive and involontary exclusive,

some pokemon were for a long time involontary exclusive on pro like carnivine only due to a involontary lack of spawn which naturally fixes with time and the addition of new spawn.

Wich is not the same case for exclusive Pokemons which are voluntary Exclusive pokemon like Rotom / Zorua / Porygon etc... which are the basic pokemon that are much rarer with much more interest and excitement around them or even much more usefulness.

 

 

About solosis :

 

4 total spawns including 2 exclusively during event periods and 2 MS exclusif spawn we're a long way from a pokemon that can be found absolutely everywhere.

 

For Bouffalant:

 

Unfortunately I think you must have confused Africa with America or maybe confused with another animal because the "bouffalant" animal species lives in Europe and North America in forest / plain / mountainous environments that can be snowed in at certain times of the year, so I don't see any problem and seems totaly fine and logic to finding  some bouffalant here. 

 

Even in pokemon go Bouffalant spawn is Based arround NewYork wich is in North America

 

 

 

 

About Eevee Forms: @Phuongismylife

 

There are maps dedicated to the different form of Eevee wich are announced in the Pro Discord announcement

 

 

 

So if you only want the 2023 Eevee Form you need to hunt Eevee in Cryofrost Path spawn and if you want the 2018 Eevee form you need to hunt in Frost valley  spawn.

 

All others Spawn are "RNG" and the rate is 50/50 between both Eevee form 

 

 

 

Thanks to both of you for taking the time to make suggestions and give feedback that could improve spawns.

Wishing you a good day and kind regards,
CloseCombat.

 

Edited December 12, 2023 by Closecombat

[Finnderboss]

dont wanna argue about bisons or buffalos just giving bad and confused feedback.
solosis 4 spawns outside of unova with tier 8 is a big difference compared to 1 tier 9 spot on trainers valley.
carnivine is a rare safari exclusive spawn like croagunk in the original games, james pokemon and in mystery dungeon even a boss idk why u compare it to starly they have nothing in common.
just switch excavation spawns or other stuff that people actually been waiting for.

Edited December 12, 2023 by Finnderboss

[Nyahoja]

Hello @Finnderboss,

Thank you for the feedback on this thread we do appreciate it, however, be sure to keep this thread SPAWN related.
I removed your last comment concerning the spawn editors. @Closecombat explained spawn editors reasons above.
As said, spawns are evolving alongside the game,despite his explanations you refuse to agree with them (which is totally fine) but please if you have any complaint towards staff members or the work they provide, you are free to use our General complain area.
Another staff member will take a look at your complain and will answer you in this one.

Hope that you will understand,
Nyahoja.

[Closecombat]

Hello @Finnderboss

 

Solosis and gen 5/6 Pokemons:

5 hours ago, Finnderboss said:

solosis 4 spawns outside of unova with tier 8 is a big difference compared to 1 tier 9 spot on trainers valley.

We're not waiting for unova to be released to add spawns to 5th generation pokemon,

we're working to make these pokemons accessible despite the current absence of their native region(Unova/Kalos). This can be done by adding MS spawns in certain regions or by adding new spawns to the map.

Solosis has the right and deserves to have access to more spawns on the game, wich is currently 4 (even two 9-10 months /12 when we are not in Xmas / Hw Event).

 

About Carnivine:

 

I already Explain everything about it in my last post and being a boss in mystery dungeon doesn't change that and starly was just one example of the many tier changes that took place in the game.

 

Changes in rarity have always existed, it's not something new.

This post was accessible to everyone at the time it was updated with all tier changes.

 

 

About Excavation:

 

  

On 7/2/2023 at 7:44 PM, Qeight said:

Do NOT post feedback about the following things:

 

• Headbutts, Digspots, Excavation sites, Boss rewards, NPC rewards
  • Those are Scripter duties and I am not able to help you with that
• Anything related to forms and form chances

 

 

Thanks you for taking the time to make suggestions and give feedback that could improve spawns.

Wishing you a good day and kind regards,
CloseCombat.

 

[Caennethi]

Hello,

 

currently Froakie is only available to hunt during Summer and Halloween Event.

It feels quite unsatisfying to not be able to catch Froakie till Summer Event.

A Froakie spot outside of event maps would be helpful.

Greetings ~Caennethi

[Crucifixuz]

I also wanna give bad feedback about the carnivine spawn change...  he is one of the rarest pokes in d&p and more exclusive than croagunk etc in the original games (only safari when u approach the telescope) and they are still exclusive tier 8 pokes!!! and carnivine is now uncommon even with multiple spawns??? how could that happend and not be reverted even after someone noticed ?