Leaderboard

Concern First of all, thanks for letting us share our concerns, i'm going into the obvious one, the treatment between certain staffs and players. We all know that how Qeight treat us players with incredibly rudeness, the issue is not just that (as if being treated like [heck]/dumb and other insults towards the community was small thing), but sometimes we see in pro discord ban threats. As far as i imagine, this is totally unacceptable, the lack of respect when someone does a question about something they DON'T UNDERSTAND, it's apparent, i will say that for myself, but every time i see this happening, i feel less and less motivated to speak in pro discord or even play pro. i'm a 2k +hours player and the fear of being punished (banned) because i said something a staff disliked it's bigger than my will to play. Another concern, but also a suggestion would be, don't let staff, being in game or discord that had troubles with certain players, to give their "opinion" about an infraction. That is totally based on emotion therefore, makes the judgment clouded and personal instead of technical. For a GM, the infraction can be a 2 hours mute, to the one with grudge will be worth of a ban, I myself was almost victim of that kind of judgment, and it's totally not fair. Suggestion 1- Allow players to vote about the behavior of certain moderation to ensure the staff will hear us in a faster way, like an instant open public feedback. 2- Do something about not only users but moderators, that pretend that do not see offenses, homophobic comments, body shaming comments, xenophobic (offense towards ethnic groups) comments. 3- Punish the ones that provoke severely and a small warn to those who DEFEND themselves. We're often seeing the attacked ones being punished for defending their honor. 4- Try to stop the "protection culture" where, a staff says the complaint of a player towards another member of staff is wrong, if one player expressed it's concern usually there are many others who agree but don't have the courage to do so. 5- Put a recruitment based on minimum Age (hard to do but it's about free time and maturity). Thanks :RemVV:

It looks like sometimes, a certain staff member feels obliged to insult or to reply in a condescending way to players. Without targetting him/her, I would like to know why you hired him/her again and why he/she isn't fired.

Hello there everyone ! For those of you who don't know me, I am Keita, one of the Administrator of Pokemon Revolution Online, nice to meet you! Given the recent situation with increasing tensions between staff and players, I think it's now time to properly address it with the aim of improving the situation and in general the staff-player relation. The people who know me can testify that I have, and never had, a problem in being transparent and honest, but as well really direct going straight to the point. Just to clear, this doesn't mean that everything can be disclosed as there are things that cannot be disclosed like it can be the method we use to catch cheaters, but there are many other things that can be discussed without a problem and that many would be interested but are afraid to ask. This thread has been created exactly to have a ground where staff (represented in this thread by us Admins) and players can properly discuss together and clarify things. In this thread you will be able to ask me pretty much anything that passes on your mind. Some example: Moderation Our stance toward a specific behaviour Our stance toward a specific rule violation What kind of training do staff has to pass before becoming effectively a full-staff member? How does our Punishment Policy exactly works? Suggestions How they are addressed within the staff team; How do we treat them in general and what value do we give to them What priority do we give to them Staff How is staff organized How do we make sure the staff are doing the right thing and not abusing their power How is staff punished if and when they break any rule Events How do we organize them? However, do keep in mind that these are just examples but there is many more things that you might be interested in knowing and can ask here. Also, as said previously, remember that there are some things that cannot be answered, some of them can be: Exact value of special form encounter chance How do we find cheaters (as this would allow people to bypass them and have the game full of cheaters) Other things that are not in my mind now, but I will make sure to point it out to you in case you ask IMPORTANT: This is a space I am offering in order to improve the staff-player relation. I do expect transparency and honesty from you at 360°, but as well respect. No insult, taunt, provocation, targetting toward a specific user or staffmember or similar will be tolerated. We live in 2021, I am fairly sure the human society evolved enough to be able to hold a discussion with the best transparency and honesty possible but as well respect toward each other. Allowed argument: It looks like sometimes you mass ban a lot amount of people at once, why does it happen? Not allowed argument: You fucking dictator, hitler fan, you just hate the whole INSERTCOUNTRY population, why the fuck do you do that? fuck you retarded dictator

I noticed some staff are very quick to ban, sometimes with no warning, but take ages to handle appeals. Why? I would like to suggest that, if you are gonna ban someone, why not make sure to be around to handle the appeal in the same day? Or at least before the temporary ban ends, preferable within a week after banning. PRO have lots of mods, it doesn't seem to be an impossible request. Another question: Why can't I request another mod to handle my appeals if I don't trust the one doing so? I noticed poor behaviour from one of the staff and wish not to have this staff handling my appeal. And I requested that, he closed the appeal. Lemme know if you want me to name them. Also, why are staff allowed to call players "idiot" or taunt them? I saw Teerav quoting something said by a staff, and he was taunted and called stupid for that. They also avoided talking about the relevant subject Teerav quoted. Other staff ganked in to defend the staff. Pretty immature behaviour. Was something done about it? Or is it just allowed? Lemme know if you want screenshots. If the majority of the players do not appreciate how a staff is treating us or handling situations, will something be done about it? Or are we going to be ignored? Will this thread be another one of those to let players express themselves but nothing will be done about it? Please, lemme know before keep investing time in this game. Thank you for your time.

When u break the law, you have to be punished , it is good for the community, PRO 'staff is very fair and honest , i have no opinion

I feel like the best way to actually communicate with the staff team about the game is the Suggestions Subforum (or at least it should be) but Suggestions almost never get answered or only get a 1 sentence answer. I know the staff team and esspecially the developers are insanly busy but some Suggestions still deserve a proper answer. We are told to always voice our opinions and make suggestions but if they never get answered in a proper way it just does not feel right. I have been told multiple times that all suggestions are being read but there is no time to give proper answers most of the time. While I can understand that to a certain extend I think there needs to be a better solution for that. For example there could be a monthly stream where suggestions are being looked into and discussed. If that is not possible because of some reasons maybe it would be possible to discuss about some suggetions within the staff team and then give a decent answer to the Suggestion Thread. If there are other reasons why suggestions rarely get answered please share these reasons with us so we can understand it.

Well ... my first account got banned forever because staff pretended I cheated when me and my brother play from the same network and same pc and called me a liar even when i gives him a prove and he didn't Note: my account have 3000 hours play and I didn't have any penalties before Question: what kind of democracy is is this if we can't defend on our self?

@Qeight i have a question to you. You dont play PRO, i mean u can log into ur acc sometimes, but never to actually play the game itself. You know, more than half of the community dont like you, and also u dont like the community back (or a big part of it), so my question is: Why, why u still around? whats the reason for it? just curious tbh.

First of all, i'd like to disclose that this miscommunication or non-communication between staff and players have gone long enough, and most of you know when that started and with whom. Going back from there, the 2016 era had barely any issues with players. One of PRO's key selling points back then was and i quote "Staff are friendly, rules are fair and strict, no favoritism" this has change dramaticaly over the years, and not in a good way i'm afraid. I have yet to see App's or more than 60% of the remaining staff interacting with the community, casually talking or just having fun with players on a daily basis. One of the key requirements for passing App was to be able to interact with the community. What sort of procedure does app and staff follow these days on player interaction? From the original PP that was created by myself and few other staff, rules are not being enforced strict enough or have been enforced in a more discretional way, does PP still intend as a deterrant for toxic people? If so does the goal "keep the game fair for players" still apply as a driving factor on adapting PP to situations. What are the criterea's for a suggestion to reach staff? A: just forums B: some good bits here and there - Unfortunately i dont see many back and forth dialogs in suggestions between player and staff to help them improve their suggestions. is it? from what i can tell only content team is somewhat organized, but even within content everyone is responsible for their own things rather than working as a collective, based on dialogs with other CS's. I think its more healthy to ask what is "abuse" at this point. Because while some of the things that can be seen as abuse on a regular basis it seems like its completely fine on a staff point of view. As for a question of my own, how does recruitment policy works? Are there any ideas to let go of the "fill the forum" application and actually communicating with the person that might become your team mate for understanding people better. This is a fanmade game, not a job. EDIT: In the past, we had a policy to allow players to ask someone else handle the appeal if a player was not satisfied with the answer provided, is this still a common practice in how appeals are being handled this time around?

This is what I was going to bring up as well, I'm fairly sure we may be thinking of the same staff member. I've seen screenshots of him being disrespectful and rude to both active and banned players (falsely banned or otherwise.) Talking down to them, mocking them, making jabs at them. Far be it from me to tell you guys how to control your staff, but I've administrated a lot of forums in my time and that dude would have been gone long ago. Every single person here deserves to be treated with respect until they've proven extremely undeserving of it, this particular staff member seems unwilling to do that. I have a feeling we don't even need to name that staff member, from the few staff members I have spoken to he's a known issue among you guys... Yet he's still here? I know a lot of you guys are great and care about the game and it's community, but staff members like that are giving you a very bad name among the playerbase.

I'm desperately waiting for some chad former staff or an OG player to come air some staff dirty laundry right now , because oh boy I've heard some juicy stuff.

bring back Shane and Shamac everything will be perfectly fine

This thread is just a waste, if your staff team aka q8 can't even see where he is wrong and why people dislike the gm then close the thread instead just like all the other ones. These issue have been since i started on my first account in 2018 and here we are again with another thread that will solve literally nothing, but whatever.

Even if it happened to me in the past to be sometimes aggressive towards certain staff members, I will remain objective, impartial in my argument. Even if I think that staff members invest a lot of time in their tasks, I think that it is badly distributed, and sometimes for things that do not make sense or do not go in the direction of the players. 4 argued examples: 1) Summer tournament 2020. I really enjoyed the one in 2019 (the first and only one in which I participated), it allowed me to meet lots of players and sometimes to advise or be advised in PvP. I expected to participate in the 2020 one. In this regard, announcements had been made on this subject for the registrations for the 2020 tournament. Then, radio silence, no more news or much too late. I think a lot of time was invested to get the mega released in time for this tournament. However, we played for years without a mega, so I don't think it was dramatic if we have summer tournament without the mega. Strictly speaking, a winter tournament could have been proposed to play with the new megas. The summer tournament seemed like a tradition to me, an event that only happens once every year. To sump up with this example: · The staff missed his communication by opening the registrations and then leaving the players in artistic vagueness. · Then the time invested on the megas did not benefit the players who wanted to participate in the summer tournament. Personally, I am disappointed not to have been able to compete in the summer tournament, especially since there was no reason to cancel it. It pissed me off. 2) Jet ski speed / Surf mounts. It is the perfect example which proves the dysfunctions between staff and players. First, we nerfed jetski. One day later after received many complaints, you have decided to reimburse players for a coin capsule for those who no longer wish to use this surf mount. The reimbursement was a good thing, but really to late (one day is really too late… ). Indeed, some players decided to sell their jetski at prices divided by 2 to 3 the original value. Second, for a very long time you did not explain why you made this decision to nerf the speed of the jetski. Then you explained why you nerfed Jetski, for more diversity, totally understandable Third, I think this decision was the worst to take. 4 options were available to you: - nerf the jetski and reimburse players with a coin capsule and improve the speed of other surf mounts (but these don't go as fast as the jetski) - increase the speed of the surf mounts to the same speed as the Jetski and reimburse the players with a coin capsule for the players who no longer want their Jetski. - reimburse the players with a coin capsule for players who no longer want their Jetski and put the price of the jetskis at the same price as the other surf mounts in the shop. You took the worst decision. Fourth, I decided to make a suggestion about this topic. No one answered me. So I decided to make my suggestion in a popular and debated thread, where I was obviously off topic and was more likely to get an answer. Walross clearly told me that I was off topic (which was true). He explained to me that the subject was closed and that it was not worth discussing it any longer. It doesn't seem to me to be an attitude of dialogue between players and staff. This attitude and decision to nerf the speed of the Jetski that makes no sense pissed me off once again. 3) Guild tournament. Although this tournament is a first, in my opinion there has been a lack of organization and a total ignorance of the players who want to finish the tournament. We waited too long for nothing. Instability of the servers is not a valid apology, there were easier ways to end this tournament quickly. No needs to mention the delays caused by some teams who easily took their time between each round. 4-5 rounds gap between the winner and loser bracket… To sum up, this tournament revealed several things: - a lack of organization - poor communication - ignorance of the players on the part of some members of the staff who probably considered that the players were not important. - apparent conflicts between staff members 4) Respect. I already feel the mockery coming about this subject, especially when this remark comes from me. I tried many ways to discuss with staff: · calm and constructed · aggressive and constructed (I tried the aggressivity when I’m really pissed off about attitude and decisions of staff) · comical Before being aggressive, some staff members have missed and perhaps lack respect to the players. I think it's important to name people so I'll give some names. For example, I spoke to logan about Predators Guild Drama about the power in this guild via discord. The first sentence I received from LOGAN is: “Should I ban you?”. I'm not a child, and I think there is a better way to express yourself, including starting by saying “hello “and not being contemptuous towards players. I don’t have personal problem with Prehax / Qeight / Felix, but I saw that some of his answers are both contemptuous of the players and the staff members. When I saw thread from Prehax, I have the feeling that the staff do not shake one of them and he’s the only ones able to do something, a kind of superhero or savior, I do not like this behavior. He disrespects some players when they try to make some suggestions without being aggressive and get censored because it does not go in his opinion. If we read my post, don’t be upset, I tried to be as impartial as possible. I pointed out the dysfunctions, but I know that there is a desire to do well among certain members of the staff. Do not consider my post as criticism aimed at overwhelming the staff. My english is bad. If you want more explanations, feel free to contact me

Edit: I made a mistake and didnt put the context in the above pictures. Im sorry for that, because apparently its ok as pro staffer to insult people and use bad language if they post 'stupid' stuff. If you want the full context, please search this stuff in the pro discord and only then make yoursef a opinion on it. No idea why many people dont like staff, abselutely no idea. Sadly the impact of a few loud have also impact of all other staffs, the generalization happens pretty fast. Its smt natural in a humans brain. Imagine you are new to the game and this is the first impression of staff. I only have screens from him because its current, the most obvious and I didnt had to search long. But there are also other staffs which lost their good tone a couple of times. Its obvious that there are many players much worse than that, but as staffer you should always have a bit proffesionalism - no matter if they talk with someone who does the same. I also read many appeals from my friends, because their english is not so well for example. And its crazy how unfriendly and snootily staffs answere there (but also not only there) sometimes. They missunderstand stuff and dont even say sorry afterwards for example. Its not a crime to say that you are wrong in some points - some staff members completely refuse to do that sometimes. Ofc many people dont trust staff about game content announcements, even when many additions are good, they often getting not as much appreciated because they got announced to be published long times ago or with the publishing the server starts crashing much more often. Corsi island is also a example. PRO summer tour 2020. I advise anyone new to not expect much from changes, and that no eta defenitely doesnt has to mean 'soon'. Exclude the totally disgusting server crashes, the game actually makes fun and is cool content wise, but with all those impressions its hard to believe myself. There is a bit more but in the end it sums up in those 2 main points. So, for me its no wonder that players (at least for many that I know including myself) dont really trust many staffers and I cant disagree that some staff members act like ... not staff members to word it kindly, which has impact how you see the whole team.

r/lostredditors

@Shinohara You know the main reason why the player - staff relation is going down hill. Not just that, even the motivation of staff in general. Which leads to less motivation to interact in the first place. Everything shown here and posted on pro discord is nothing different than what happens in the staff circle itself and its no secret why it happens. The only real question is how long will it continue, until there are changes or until its too late?

If most people thought the earth was flat, would it be flat?

just rename this topic to prehax hate thread already y'all ask for more communication from staff, he communicates his opinions and doesn't veil them behind diplomatic language - is this not the transparency people ask for? his dismissiveness of opinions he doesnt agree with is the primary issue between staff and players? please. not everyone is good at putting on a fake smile and lying to your face that they'll "think about it." makes perfect sense why others avoid interacting with this community like the plague. good riddance.

In every community, there are problematic people who tarnish by themselves the reputation of the whole community. The PRO staff member community is not an exception of this rule. In my opinion, 99% of the staff members are making a really good job, taking the good decisions, are reactive and really cool with players. This is very important to say, most of you guy are really making a geat job. BUT the 1% left drag down the staff reputation with their really contestable actions. And when I say 1%, I personnally have one person in mind. To not target toward a specific staffmember, I will not give names but let's use a nickname and call him "Mister P.". Mister P. is hated by a large majority of PRO players. Power abusing, insulting, condescending comments against players etc... always playing with the limits. A lot of people are complaining about him. The bad behavior of Mister P. impacts the reputation of staff members. So my question is simple : Why Mister P. is not fired yet ? Suggestion : If you have many complains about one specific staff member, make a democratic poll and let the PRO players take the decision.

I just came here to read the comments

Heyho, the other points will certainly be answered by Keita or other staffs. I would like to concentrate on the second point first, because I do not want to leave it as it is. As you mentioned, I nerfed the speed of jet skis from 8 to 6, as all players used jet skis because of the speed and not the optics. That highly devalued all other surf mounts for literally no reason! The other surf mounts had a speed of 4, which is the normal running speed, and therefore players only used jet skis. I considered whether I should increase the speed of the surf mounts to 8, but the animations of some mounts looked very bad at this speed. That's why I nerfed the speed of jet skis from 8 to 6 and buffed that of every other mount from 4 to 6. That's exactly how I announced it at the time. Furthermore, it took a day to add the NPC to exchange a jet skis for a CC because it had to be tested first. It had nothing to do with the reaction from the community.

Hi there i think we all agreed that we are here to have fun and at the same time we want healthy community the relationship between the players and staffs are part of this community so you must chose your staffs carefully my suggestion to you is making evaluation that allow us to evaluate the staffs every month in the end of every season and the one who get a low rate should be replaced .. you have to make balance between the staffs and the players but in fact you dont you just gave the staffs the power to do every thing they want without the ability to make an objection and btw your hole appeal system need to changed so we can have a fair discussion .. otherwise the problems between players and staffs will stay the same or maybe will get worse in future

Hi there @biermon12 As the situation you have experienced happened before I was Admin (and from a person that is now a Former Staff) I have went over and checked the case where the event you described happened. You were being checked for a Real Money Trading situation and there were really strong evidences pointing toward you. The staff member, in order to help you getting out it (and not losing your account), actually had the WRONG idea to actually ask you for a photo to prove your claim (of being friends/brothers playing together). Despite the staff had good intentions, what the Staff Member did is absolutely wrong and is something we are absolutely against and always taught to not do that (although that should be common sense). Despite I was not an Admin back then and therefore had no management power, I do give you our most sincere apologies regarding the event you have experienced with a promise to do my best in order to make sure that was the first and last time something like that will happen. - Keita

Event Form : Xmas Mr.mine Time investment : 30mins Possibly interest to join staff either as pixel artist or coin shop icon creator : no

You should see some of our private discords with staff, we rip them apart on every chance xD But no, that would do more harm than good

.

This is not the main topic. Maybe for you, not for everybody

Wrong. It works both ways. Some staff make all staff look bad and YOU make players look bad. Shinohara is clearly going post by post according to the date they have been posted. Next up is MaitrePoulpe. Yours will be answered too.

there is no relation between players & staff and if this continue i see it will be the end of pro

Well I've noticed that lately there are too many complaints about community being treated in a "shitty" way and I agree on that. Being treated like that will not help the game but it will have the complete opposed effect, resulting in people quitting it. When I raged in PRO discord about the state of the servers I got treated kinda well by most of the staff there (to be fair with everyone), then there is one staff member (who works hard and we all know that) who couldn't resist the temptation to taunt us (I consider me particularly) by posting an announcement stating that if we are tilted from PvP (which wasn't the case) or just bored, we can help staff members to improve the translation to Russian and other languages of forums. Well, when many don't consider it as an offense, I took it personally and brought it up to many players who agreed that this particular staff member is really rude to constructive criticism (My case wasn't so constructive, but gave some ideas in Discord, not in forums for obvious reasons stated in other comments). As I said before, a game is nothing without its community and when you treat this community badly, don't expect them to stick to the game. PEACE

Has a Staff ever reinvestigated their given punishment after putting an end to the appeals ? Just wondering if such thing as amnesty did happen or not.

I think most of these I already understand except the discussion of suggestions. I think this is a very lacking area even if someone in staff is in charge of this. 1. I know for a fact that if anyone is in charge of it would have to be a GM or someone high up because I have never seen it. The only exception I could see is content scripters maybe look for content related suggestions but I just feel from expefience this is not the case. 2. There seems to be no reply in suggestion forums to well done posts and it drives a lot of frustration within the community about just being ignored. Recently, Wally answered to the issue of PvP queue problems that I pulled verbatum from forum suggestion thread and it was only finally getting him to talk to us randomly in our Discord did it seem this got looked at. While I am not a fan of just getting a reply that it will not be done/cannot be done and then just leave it at that, like I have had done to me years ago, it is better than silence. 3. The Q and A streams seem to have no correlation to the suggestion thread which I really wish it would. The streams just seem rather random to some extent I guess to answer topical questions but I think there is room to improve this all if we had more dedicated looks at the suggestion thread and actually hearing replies. Staff Related Optional Point: I think there are those in staff who do not really have a way to voice proper criticism or advice in a way that can actually help. We can argue all day whether I got ignored or not and if I just baby raged left staff over this but I really cannot necessarily blame Wally for not being able to know all the criticism and advice I have given necessarily with how busy he is and Discord just buries these topics. There seems to be channels kind of geared slightly for this but they seem either not really used or just not designed to properly engage us.

my suggestion is to lighten up on the rules in battle chat and let people rage there a bit, alot of people get muted directly from things in battle chat and im sure everyone knows pvp brings frustration always so some people just cant help but express themselves. If you make battle chat an optional chat and make it so people have to join the chat themselves instead of it already being there it will keep alot of the sensitive people out. im sure people wont like this idea but battling and war is all about violence so i dont see why the chat cant be a warzone too yaknow.

Price dropped, if there wont be any bid within 24hours I'm gonna cancel the auction and keep it. Start : 5M Min Bid. 250k No Insta 48 hours from the start bid Accepted Payments: Pokedollar IV Reroll Ticket 750k Nature Reroll Ticket 370k Coin Capsule 370k The Pokemon is in Gold Server I am willing to transfer.

I think one of the main reasons people hate staff members on pro is Caps. They can use caps we can't. And from a psychological stand of view they look like some bunch of liberals typing while watching us from their high heels.. I'd love to use CAPS someday sincerely. yours truly.

Some people's punishments that they received via battle Chat is way too harsh for the crime.

.

just fun fact: some ppl replying in this thread (as players), kinda ''protecting'' staffers, are/were staffers before

.

The person just thinks it's okay to call others stupid and idiot. Need to say something else?

Most of pro's community consider him a bad staff member, and a Power abuser, do you think most of us are wrong and he is right ?

It would be good to avoid harassing players by private messages on discord and threatening to ban them if they do not respond to you within 10 minutes of your message: In my case he was a GM who is no longer in the staff now, I answered all his questions all day while being respectful but he came back to see me several hours later and it was dark at home so I was asleep I could not answer him right away, by connecting to discord I could see many notifications from him where he threatened to ban me if I did not answer him literally 10 minutes after he asked his question. from there he kept threatening to ban me if I didn't answer him within 5min. It was really a really bad experience to go through this for several days it almost made me stop playing the game. I understand that a GM has to react quickly when there is a problem but we players have a life also we cannot be at your entire disposal for several days to answer your questions immediately, especially since I answered all his messages as soon as I saw them. I don't know if this is usual with you or if it was just the person's method, but this kind of action is not pleasant for the players. Imagine being threatened with wasting your thousands of hours of farming multiple times just because you didn't immediately respond to a staff member's question via a private message on Discord that makes you lose all desire to play the game. I'm surely not the only person to have had this bad experience. Kinds regards.

Based take for everyone thinking to respond or this might get deleted before you read it, this is a fan made pokemon game not a democracy. Your vote doesn't matter and your opinion doesn't either. You can't change someone's online presence by complaining or reacting negatively. I get its 2021 but that's your based take from me.

Event form: SW Marowak-Alolan (Darth Maul) Time investment: 2hrs (although i started it the day before yesterday) Possibly interest to join staff either as Pixel Artist or Coin Shop icon creator: No Graphic: Poor lightsaber rip

INTRODUCTION - (Make sure to open the spoilers) - Lets get straight to the point, Excavation Sites need an update. The last big change to Excavation Sites was about 1 1/2 years ago, so the spawns and features have been very stale for quite some time already. Now I know that scripters and other staff members are extremly busy and try their best to get out new content like events, megastone-quests and much more but I still want to put out this suggestion as Excavation Sites are a great PvE task you can do from time to time or even daily which makes the game much more enjoyable for a lot of players. I dont want Excavation Sites to be forgotten and since the question about new spawns etc. keeps getting repeated on every previous Q&A-Stream, this thread can also serve as some sort of a platform for everyone to share their ideas and opinions on this topic. Maybe if all the megastone-quests are done there is some time to make some changes to the Excavation Sites. TL;DR SPAWNS & ITEMS Credits for some provided ideas Change Pokemon Spawns Straight to the most important thing regarding Excavation Sites, the Spawns. The Spawns have not been changed for a long time and it is simply not fun nor rewarding to catch the same pokemon over and over again. Previous changes introduced outbreak- and event-exclusive pokemon which make certain pokemon very special and hard to obtain. Adding some of these to Excavation Sites would be a first step to make them very interesting and rewarding again while still keeping them balanced as there are only a limited number of spawns you can get daily. Events and Outbreaks which have these pokemon as spawns would still be special as you can hunt them actively on these. Other pokemon got more attractive recently as well. With the introduction of their mega-evolution some previously ignored pokemon became relevant and most of these would make a very good addition to Excavation Sites. Another thing I want to suggest are pokemon which are exclusive to Excavation Sites like new Gen7 pokemon, as this would raise them to another level of interest. TL;DR Balancing the Spawns I dont know exactly how the spaw-mechanics etc. work but I tried to suggest the spawns in a way to make them somewhat balanced while keeping the theme of the different Excavation Sites. However the suggested changes are obviously not perfect and probably need more in-depth balancing. I would suggest to keep/add very good and exclusive spawns to the Excavation Sites and to balance the cooldown or the entry-costs instead. By increasing the cooldown or the entry-costs instead of the actual spawns Excavation Sites will feel exciting and worth while doing them. TL;DR Spawn Change Suggestions (Note: These are just examples to give some ideas for spawn changes, feel free to share your thoughts and ideas in the comments) Credits for some ideas on the spawn changes and source for provided data Feral Site Historical Site Haunted Site Mineral Site Glacial Site Natural Site Wondrous Site Briny Site Draconic Site Changes to available items First of all Fossils fit well into Excavation Sites and can even be synched with an NPC in the Historical Site. Revival Herbs are always useful for rather new players and can still be useful to more advanced players as they can be used on quests, events, leveling pokemon etc. While Heal and Energy Powder may be useful to a certain extend to newer players, they feel like a waste for most of the playerbase after a while. I would suggest to change them to items which are pretty much always needed and useful like Vitamins (Protein, Iron, HP Up etc.) or make Heal and Energy Powder exchangable for Artifact pieces. I think the previous change which added different rare items (Rare Bone, Nuggets, Pearls etc.) in the different Excavation Sites was not thought through well enough as less-valuable items are more common and make it harder to encounter pokemon because of that while valuable items are too rare to have an impact. Therefor less-valuable items should be removed and replaced with more valuable items. That way its less likely to find items and more likely to actually encounter rare pokemon. Since the different items seem to have different drop-rates I suggest to replace all items with the same item for every Excavation Site to make it more balanced. Replacing all the items with a Nugget seems to make the most sense as it has a decent value and is not found too often which makes it more likely to encounter a pokemon. The chance for a Big Nugget should be increased as its near impossible to find it (I personally found only one while increasing my Excavation Rank from 10.000 to 36.000+). This makes achieving an Excavation Rank of 10.000 to unlock the Draconic Site and that particular Excavation Site less worth and that is a clear balance-issue in my opinion. To give some further insight regarding this, @JustLegend did some research on Excavation Sites some time ago. The data he collected shows that 47 Tiny Mushrooms and 0 Big Nuggets were found after 28 days of doing every Excavation Site. Because of this it is somewhat harder to encounter pokemon in the Haunted Site which is another balance-issue. Make sure to check out his thread for more in-depth data regarding Excavation Sites. Credits for provided data TL;DR Changes to Artifact Pieces Store For most of the time my personal experience with the Artifact Pieces shop has been that I would only buy Focus Sashes as these are the most valuable items you can get and they are rather easy to sell. Most other items are not worth their price, are not needed or have other sources you can get them from easily. To give Artifact Pieces a better use I suggest to lower some prices in a balanced way to make it worth buying other items than focus sashes and a few other items. Balancing prices and available items is not easy by any means but I tried to come up with fair prices based on a calculation. To understand the suggested Artifact Pieces prices and that calculation you need to know some numbers. For a full Excavation Site run we end up with an average of 64 Artifact pieces (I used 60 for cleaner calculations) and a Focus Sash costs 6 Artifact pieces and sells for about 2.000 - 2.500 Pokedollar (I used 2.000 Pokedollar for the calcuation). Buying 10 Focus Sashes for 60 Artifact Pieces and selling them for 2.000 Pokedollar each leads to a daily profit of 20.000 pokedollars. Example of the calcuation based on a Reroll Ticket: -> Reroll Ticket (2.250) -> 750.000 / 20.000 = 37.5 -> 37.5 x 60 = 2.250 -> Reroll Ticket (2.250) -> 750.000 (Current average price of a Reroll Ticket) / 20.000 (daily profit from selling Focus Sashes) = 37.5 (days to purchase a Reroll Ticket from another player if selling the Focus Sashes daily) -> 37.5 x 60 (Artifact Pieces gained daily from a full Excavation Sites run) = 2.250 (price of a Reroll Ticket in Artifact Pieces) The goal is to end up with item prices which are somewhat balanced in a way that makes the items worth buying instead of selling the Focus Sashes and buying the desired items from another source. Fossils: I dont know why Omanytes and Kabutos Fossils are not available yet but I would suggest to add them as they are the only missing Fossils. I think the prices for Fossils are too expensive overall but I did not change them too much since I dont know if there is some in-depth balancing behind that and the fact that they are untradable. Vitamins: Adjusted the prices so you are able to buy 10 Vitamins after a full Excavation Sites run. Consumables: Adding certain items like Reroll Tickets to the Artifact Pieces Shop makes Excavation Sites even more lucrative. However I did not suggest more random items to keep the theme of the Excavation Sites alive for the most part but I think Reroll Tickets can be a very good addition as they serve as a more or less long-term-goal players can work for. Battle Items: Adjusted the prices based on the explained calculation. I did not suggest additional items as the already existing ones fit the Excavation Sites them perfectly well. TM Moves: Adjusted the prices based on the explained calculation and added the TM for Substitute since it is only available in Trainers Valley so far. Gems: Adjusted the prices so you are able to buy 10 Gems after a full Excavation Sites run. It could be considered to lower the prices even further given the Gems cheap price in Pokedollars and easy obtainability on dig spots but they can be used on the Recycle NPC as well which could possibly lead to imbalanced results. Evolution Items: Adjusted the prices based on the explained calculation. Damage-reducing Berries: Adjusted the prices so you are able to buy 10 Berries after a full Excavation Sites run. Since stat-modifying berries like the Salac berry are still rather hard to come by I think they would create great interest towards the Excavaton Sites. Mega Stones: Since obtaining 1.000 Artifact Pieces to purchase a megastone takes over 2 weeks of full Excavation Site runs and megastone-quests usually do not take longer than a 1-2 days at most for the majority of the playerbase I would suggest to lower the price a little bit to 600. While I think adding megastones exclusive to Excavation Sites is a good way to make them interesting again it should be considered that some players do not like to do Excavation Sites as well. I think lowering the price from 1.000 to 600 Artifact Pieces would be a good change which could motivate some players to do more Excavation Sites again. Obviously players who already bought the megastones for the original price of 1.000 Artifact Pieces would need to get compensated with the extra Artifact Pieces. Exclusive Cosmetic Items Shoutout to @dangarangs for the idea and some examples. https://pokemonrevolution.net/forum/topic/155148-excavation-only-cosmetics/ Adding Cosmetics and Mounts exclusive to Excavation Sites would make them a lot more interesting for not only advanced but for newer players as well. These items would give players another long-term goal depending on the price. It could be considered to make some Cosmetics and Mounts unlockable after reaching a certain Excavation Rank which would give the Excavation Rank another purpose after reaching the 10.000 mark to unlock the Draconic Site. The prices of these exclusive items would come down to the fact if they are tradable or not. TL;DR ADDITIONAL IDEAS Option to see available Excavation Site Spawns While I know its possible to check an Excavation Sites Spawns using the Reborn Bot I still think it would be a great addition for some players to know which pokemon are obtainable on the different Excavation Sites. It would be very useful to know which synchronize should be used especially. Since I dont know if its possible to add the spawns on the drop-menu on the top-left this could be done by wandering pokemon, NPCs giving hints on dialogues, signs which explain pokemon sightings etc. instead. Artifact Pieces to spawn rare pokemon I think the option to spawn certain pokemon available on the Excavation Sites would be a great addition. Once again it could be considered to make some pokemon unlockable after reaching a certain Excavation Rank which would give the Excavation Rank another purpose after reaching the 10.000 mark to unlock the Draconic Site. It could be done similar to the already existing system to spawn pokemon for PvE Coins. A changing pool of rare pokemon available in Excavation Sites which can be spawned for Artifact Pieces at an NPC. Additional Excavation Rank Rewards Currently the highest Excavation tier is Tomb Raider at 8.000+ discoveries and the 10.000 mark is the last useful rank since it unlocks the Draconic Site. I would suggest to award players for every additional 1.000 discoveries to give them another goal to grind for after achieving the 10.000 mark. It probably would make the most sense to reward players with a certain amount of Artifact Pieces. In addition players could unlock exclusive Cosmetics/Mounts and rare pokemon spawns for Artifact Pieces as mentioned earlier. Changes to Shiny Rocks I think Shiny Rocks should always have a pokemon instead of a chance for an item or even nothing. Getting a shiny out of Excavation Sites is already extremly rare and getting an item or nothing out of them is just frustrating and does not feel rewarding at all. I personally have gotten one shiny at 60.000+ Excavation Rank to give some further insights. ENDING WORDS I am well aware that not all of the suggested changes have a chance to get added to the game but I hope that at least some of these ideas will be considered and added in the future to improve the Excavation Sites again. Please feel free to share your own ideas and suggestions on this thread in the comments as well. Also dont hesitate to provide feedback on this suggestions, what do you like, what dont you like? I am looking forward to see Excavation Sites being interesting and exciting again. #MakeExcavationGreatAgain

Same case on discord, you are literally a retard and u lack braincells if u write your opinions.

.

Love these additions, Copycat should help make things a lot less grindy for new players going through Hoenn/Sinnoh.